Post Mortem

The PDA’s lack of integrity

By Nagaland Post | Publish Date: 2/5/2019 12:34:01 PM IST

 (From previous issue)

The Independence Day or the Republic Day speech is approved by the State Cabinet, and whoever unfurls the National Flag used to read it out. On 27th January 2019, the front pages of local papers carried the speech of the Governor in which the PDA vehemently defended its June 2018 decision that Nagaland is insulated by the existing laws. In other words, Nagaland needs not worry about opposing or rejecting the CAB 2016. 
Whereas, on the spurt of the moment and within 24 hours, the PDA decided ‘to oppose and reject the CAB’ on 28th January, 2019. Till 26th January, 2019, Nagaland remained safe from whatever may become the consequences of CAB when enacted as per the wisdom of PDA. What prompted PDA to lose confidence in Art 371(A) and BEFR the next day? The PDA has been so confident on the safety of Nagaland under Art 371(A) and ILP from June, 2018 till 27th January, 2019. The powers vested in these legal provisions remained the same and will continue to remain so. The PDA does not need to undermine our constitutional provisions. 
During this period of 8 months, the States of Meghalaya, Mizoram and Manipur made it clear to Union Govt. that the Bill is rejected. Whereas, PDA had voted for the Bill in Lok Sabha on 8.1.2019 and after 20 days PDA retracted and decided to reject the Bill. How PDA thought that within 20 days time, the Naga protective laws have lost its teeth to bite? This very inconsistent political stance of PDA reminds me of an old Naga adage. A bird by name ‘Khrovȕ’ has the habit of laying egg on one ridge and hatches on the other ridge. What is the logic or legal benefit it bears for PDA to reject the Bill when it has already voted for the Bill in Lok Sabha? 
Look at the languages of PDA and NDPP as I watched. How incoherent and shameless for them to say that it has never supported the CAB when PDA had voted for it on 8.1.2019. Do PDA/NDPP believe that the people of Nagaland have forgotten what you have made CAB 2016 to be a powerful Bill 20 days ago and now awaiting for the Raja Sabha to make it into an Act? Can your decision on 28.1.2019 undo what you had done on 8.1.2019? Yet, quoting a news report dated 2.2.2019 ‘the NDPP and the PDA Govt. had ‘never supported the CAB at any point of time’. What do PDA/NDPP mean by voting for the Bill and yet called it not supporting? In the political parlance of PDA/NDPP, what do you mean by voting for? Tell the Nagas.
I also question those NGOs and Civil Organisations who responded to the so-called consultative meeting sponsored by PDA on 31.1.2019 in which the same issue was discussed and resolved. Are you, the participants, convinced that PDA had practically opposed the Bill at any point of time till it was passed in Lok Sabha? Are you confident that your joint resolution adopted on that day can undo what was done on 8.1.2019? Which one of you, the PDA or the respondents is taking which one for a ride? With such integrity, can you really defend for the interest of the State? Its time for Tribal Hohos and NGOs to come out of our cocoons and call a spade spade.
Figuratively speaking, a single MP in a House of 540 odd MPs is like throwing a pebble in a pond. The PDA staging a walk out by an MP from voting when the Bill was voted cannot change the scenario in Parliament. Yet, it is a record so registered which is historical and significant. Indeed it matters in parliamentary practices and so also doing not matters. 
The PDA/NDPP is proved never embarrassed, hesitant or restraint to tell lies. Yet, it is painful for the sensible people to observe how the highest authorities have become very articulated and professional liars. It would have been more respectable for these authorities to admit its folly and appreciate the wisdom of those States and others who are talking sense while eating its vomit. Trying to defend its designed treachery has dented its image deeper. Such attempts to escape from blame with immature and evasive statements are like ostrich hiding in the bush. Yet, opposing the Bill by anybody is better than not.
Z. Lohe 

Launched on December 3,1990. Nagaland Post is the first and highest circulated newspaper of Nagaland state. Nagaland Post is also the first newspaper in Nagaland to be published in multi-colour.

Desk:+91-3862-248 489, e-mail: Fax: +91-3862-248 500
Advt.:+91-3862-248 267,



Join us on

© Nagaland Post 2018. All Rights are Reserved
Designed by : 4C Plus